argumentum.cz
CZ EN DE

All practice areas

Supreme and Constitutional Court appeals

We prepare appeals on points of law, constitutional complaints and other extraordinary remedies, including in cases where we did not represent the client at lower instances.

Our cases in this area

  1. II. ÚS 2145/25precedent - Constitutional CourtThe defence must be able to respond to the prosecutor's appeal before the court decides on pre-trial detention.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 10 September 2025
    N 201/132 SbNU 111
  2. II. ÚS 1689/25precedent - Constitutional CourtLong-term, mainly psychological domestic abuse can amount to maltreatment. Courts must assess the conduct as a whole, including earlier violence, its duration and its impact on the victim.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 27 August 2025
    N 189/131 SbNU 417
  3. Pl. ÚS 17/24precedent - Constitutional CourtA suspended sentence for a serious sexual offence against a child must be justified carefully and convincingly. A prior consensual relationship cannot automatically count as a mitigating factor, and blame must not be shifted onto the victim.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 19 March 2025
    N 61/129 SbNU 194
  4. III. ÚS 1711/21precedent - Constitutional CourtEarly release on parole cannot be refused mainly because of a criminal record. The court must tell the prisoner what to change.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 31 August 2021
    N 157/107 SbNU 312
  5. II. ÚS 2597/18precedent - Constitutional CourtA house search requested by another state may be ordered only if the court specifically examines dual criminality, including limitation under Czech law.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 9 April 2020
    N 69/99 SbNU 344
  6. II. ÚS 1894/14precedent - Constitutional CourtThe municipality, not the state, is liable for damage caused by municipal police carrying out the municipality's own tasks, such as clamping a car.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 9 December 2014
    N 223/75 SbNU 511
  7. II. ÚS 2095/14precedent - Constitutional CourtA preliminary contract cannot be declared void for vagueness when the parties' real intention is clear. Doing so is excessive formalism.Constitutional Court
    judgment, 8 October 2014
    N 190/75 SbNU 139
  8. 3 Tz 26/2025precedent - Supreme CourtAn appellate court may not convert an immediate prison sentence for rape into a suspended one without taking evidence itself, relying only on the defendant's assertions. A prior consensual relationship with the victim is no consent to later violence.Supreme Court
    judgment, 4 December 2025
  9. 30 Cdo 1849/2024precedent - Supreme CourtData from a seized phone must be sorted by the court: communication with defence counsel destroyed, private data clearly not needed for the proceedings kept outside the file.Supreme Court
    judgment, 16 April 2025
    Sb. rozh. obč. 36/2026
  10. 22 Cdo 524/2023precedent - Supreme CourtCo-ownership with an insufficiently identified owner can be dissolved by a court. The action may be brought even against the unknown heirs of a co-owner listed in the land register.Supreme Court
    decision, 19 December 2023
  11. 6 Tdo 42/2021precedent - Supreme CourtA person who uses force to take back their own money, of which they had been defrauded, does not take another's property and does not commit robbery.Supreme Court
    decision, 31 March 2021
    kategorie A
  12. 3 Afs 37/2024precedent - Supreme Administrative CourtA levy of 100 % of the subsidy cannot be imposed on a recipient who reacted reasonably to unforeseeable circumstances and wanted to save public money. That sanction applies only to arbitrary breaches of the rules.Supreme Administrative Court
    judgment, 24 October 2025
  13. 1 Afs 316/2021precedent - Supreme Administrative CourtA levy for breaching grant conditions cannot be set as a fixed percentage where the law requires a percentage range. The levy must match the seriousness of the breach.Supreme Administrative Court
    judgment, 19 January 2023
  14. 9 Afs 386/2018precedent - Supreme Administrative CourtA tax loss carried forward also reduces the solidarity surcharge on income tax.Supreme Administrative Court
    judgment, 19 August 2020
    Sb. NSS 4089/2020
  15. 9 Afs 166/2017precedent - Supreme Administrative CourtA professional ice hockey player holding a trade licence carries out his activity independently. What counts is the content of the contract with the club, not the mere duty to follow instructions.Supreme Administrative Court
    judgment, 6 December 2017
  16. 4 Afs 120/2017precedent - Supreme Administrative CourtA professional ice hockey player can carry on a trade and claim the 60 % flat-rate expenses. The tax authority cannot reclassify his activity merely because that is more favourable for the state.Supreme Administrative Court
    judgment, 31 August 2017

All cases

Who works in this area

How to reach us

Get in touch in whatever way suits you. We can meet in Prague, in Brno, at your place or online.

Vodičkova 704/36, 11000 Prague 1

Finding us in Palác Lucerna

+420 580 000 000

+420 608 025 820

WhatsApp and Signal

office@argumentum.cz

Burešova 615/6, 60200 Brno

Map

+420 602 802 091

brno@argumentum.cz