53 T 1/2020
acquittal
The defendant, charged with preparing to evade excise duty on tobacco (intended loss CZK 23.2 million), was acquitted because the act is not a crime. Among other things, the court criticised that surveillance began before there was any specific suspicion.
What it means
The court found that importing and storing raw tobacco does not by itself create a tax liability, and that intent in a preparatory act must be proved as strictly as for a completed offence. The High Court dismissed the prosecutor's appeal; the acquittal has been final since 26 April 2022. The client then obtained compensation for custody and house arrest, see case 28 C 90/2023.
History and sources
- Regional Court in Ústí nad Labem, Liberec branch, judgment 53 T 1/2020
- High Court in Prague, decision 10 To 18/2022
Decisions
Regional Court in Ústí nad Labem, Liberec branch, judgment 53 T 1/2020 of 14 January 2022
From the reasoning
Podezření musí být tedy dáno ještě před zahájením sledování a být důvodem pro jeho zahájení. Nelze tudíž napřed zahájit sledování a poté na základě zjištěných skutečností požádat o jeho povolení.
Avšak ani zvýšené obtíže nesmí být důvodem pro snížení standardu dokazování.